In the Republic of Korea, where freedom of religion is constitutionally protected, testimonies continue to emerge from individuals who claim they were pressured or forcibly separated from their families and communities in attempts to change their religious beliefs.
A recurring concern in these accounts is the practice of so-called "heresy counselling", through which particular religious groups are portrayed as dangerous, encouraging families to seek professional conversion services. Victims allege that some counselling processes involve deception, isolation, restrictions on personal freedom and financial transactions.
Among the prominent figures associated with heresy counselling are Pastor Yong-sik Jin, who led the Korea Christian Heresy Counselling Centre Association, and Pastor Hyun-wook Shin, director of the Guri Heresy Counselling Centre. Previous criminal proceedings involving forced conversion and continuing allegations of similar practices have raised questions about the legality of these activities and the protection of religious freedom.
◆ Similar Patterns Reported Across the Country
Victims describe recurring methods: families are encouraged to conceal their intentions, bring individuals to designated counselling locations and restrict their communication with the outside world during conversion education.
A case reported by Cheonji Ilbo in April 2015 involved a family whose son attended Shincheonji. According to the report, the family was asked to pay an initial counselling fee of 500,000 won. The family member alleged that the counsellor advised them to pretend they knew nothing about their son's faith and discussed methods of isolating him, including blocking his mobile phone.
Similar testimonies emerged during a 2016 discussion on forced conversion victims. Participants described being taken to isolated locations and subjected to conversion education against their wishes.
In another case reported in 2017, a woman identified as Eun-young Jang (pseudonym) testified that she was moved between locations and forced to undergo conversion education for 56 days. Although she eventually escaped with police assistance, she said she lost her job and became separated from her family.
The similarities between accounts from Ansan, Guri and Gwangju raise concerns about whether comparable coercive practices have been taking place across different regions.
◆ When Family Fear Becomes a Business
Victims have also questioned the financial structure surrounding conversion counselling, alleging that family anxiety is sometimes used to encourage paid counselling services.
Media reports concerning a 2012 defamation trial involving Pastor Yong-sik Jin referred to previous criminal convictions relating to coercive conversion and aiding and abetting confinement, as well as counselling fees. He was reportedly sentenced to 10 months in prison, suspended for two years, in a criminal case related to forced conversion.
In 2019, the national newspaper Cheonji Ilbo estimated that applying the standard counselling fees of the Heresy Counselling Center Association to the counselling activities of the Presbyterian Church of Korea (Hapdong) could have resulted in families paying at least 44.5 million won.
Although charging counselling fees is not inherently illegal, serious concerns arise when religious anxiety is exploited for financial gain or counselling becomes associated with coercive conversion without an individual's consent.
Critics describe this as a system that turns family fear into profit under the pretext of restoring faith.
The controversy also extends to the professional training of conversion counsellors.
In 2020, following the COVID-19 outbreak and growing public hostility towards Shincheonji, the Korea Christian Heresy Counselling Center Association operated the 'Shincheonji Counsellor Training Academy' in cooperation with Daegu CBS and other organisations.
According to media reports, Pastors Yong-sik Jin and Hyun-wook Shin participated as instructors, teaching subjects including soteriology, heresy counselling and Shincheonji counselling. Similar training initiatives subsequently expanded to regional areas, including Gwangju.
Organisers stated that the programmes aimed to help former Shincheonji members restore their faith and settle into established churches. However, their expansion during a period of heightened social hostility prompted questions about their wider purpose.
According to the World Solidarity for Religious Freedom and Human Rights (WSRF), approximately 2000 forced conversion cases have been reported since 2003. In 2020 alone, 191 cases were reported, an increase of more than 50% from the previous year and the highest annual figure in the preceding five years.
These figures raise concerns about the impact of the social climate at the time and the pressure faced by individual believers from their families.
◆ International Community Raises Concerns
The issue has also attracted attention from international religious freedom researchers and human rights organisations.
Dr Massimo Introvigne, an Italian sociologist of religion and researcher at the Center for Studies on New Religions (CESNUR), has highlighted concerns about alleged illegal conversion practices involving counsellors from certain mainstream Protestant circles in South Korea.
At the 41st session of the UN Human Rights Council in 2019, a civic organisation submitted a statement raising allegations of forced conversion involving Shincheonji members and urging the South Korean government to investigate and hold those responsible accountable.
In 2020, international researchers and religious freedom organisations also sent an open letter to the South Korean government expressing concerns about illegal conversion and religious hostility.
Although these developments do not constitute an official UN ruling on individual cases, they demonstrate that the issue has attracted international human rights attention.
◆ Religious Freedom Must Be Protected
Forced conversion is not a question of whether one religion's teachings are right or wrong. It is a fundamental human rights issue concerning whether individuals can be isolated, confined or coerced simply because of their religious beliefs.
An official from the World Solidarity for Religious Freedom and Human Rights urged investigative authorities not to dismiss forced conversion allegations as ordinary family or religious disputes.
“Investigative agencies must not dismiss reports of forced conversion as mere domestic or religious disputes. They must thoroughly investigate human rights violations, including coercion and confinement, committed during the conversion counselling process, and hold accountable those who ordered, facilitated or aided and abetted such acts.”
The official also called on religious institutions and theological seminaries to examine the legality of counsellor training programmes and disclose the operating methods and financial arrangements of counselling organisations.
They further emphasised:
“Acts that incite fear among families by labelling individuals as ‘heretics’ and exploiting that fear for coercive conversion and financial gain can never be justified in the name of religion.”
The official called on the government to strengthen preventative measures and ensure accountability wherever criminal conduct is established.
In a democratic society where freedom of religion is constitutionally guaranteed, differences in faith must never become an excuse for violating fundamental rights. Protecting religious freedom requires meaningful action from government authorities and religious communities to uphold human dignity, individual choice and the right to believe freely.
Source: vo.la/kzpcNqr






















