Shincheonji Prevails in Third Youth Reclamation Lawsuit as Court Dismisses Claims of Brainwashing and Coercion

by - 13:29

Suwon District Court
Shincheonji Church of Jesus has secured another legal victory after an appellate court rejected claims brought by two former members in the latest case relating to the so-called ‘Youth Reclamation Lawsuit’. The court upheld the original judgment, concluding that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the plaintiffs’ freedom of religious choice had been violated or that they had been subjected to unlawful coercion.

On the 11th, the 9-1st Civil Division of the Suwon District Court dismissed the appeals brought by two former members, who had each sought 5 million won in compensation from Shincheonji Church of Jesus and one of its members (Case No. 2026Na50259). The decision affirmed an earlier ruling by the Anyang Branch of the Suwon District Court, which had dismissed the claims at first instance on 19th December last year (Case No. 2020Gadan105560).

In upholding the original judgment, the appellate court stated that the lower court’s findings of fact and legal conclusions were justified.

The first-instance court found that the plaintiffs had taken part in Bible studies and religious education voluntarily, exercising their own judgment as adults. It further established that the programmes consisted of doctrinal instruction and that there was no evidence of coercion, improper inducements or financial manipulation.

The court also took into account the plaintiffs’ conduct after discovering that the teachings they had been studying were those of Shincheonji. Despite becoming aware of the church’s identity, they chose to complete their studies, formally join the organisation and subsequently participate in evangelism and ministry activities.

The judgment also addressed the circumstances of one former member who later decided to leave Shincheonji after receiving conversion education. According to the court, the church promptly removed him from its membership upon his expressing his intention to withdraw. The court found no evidence that he had been unlawfully pressured or forced to maintain his religious affiliation.

Notably, in examining the claims of another former member, the first-instance court observed that there appeared to have been instances in which some orthodox Christian believers had attempted to forcibly convert Shincheonji members.

Against this background, the court concluded that measures taken by the church, including encouraging members to submit requests for personal protection and responding cautiously to conversion-related activities, could not automatically be regarded as unlawful. Such actions would only constitute illegal conduct if coercive methods could be established.

The latest ruling marks the third lawsuit brought by former members in connection with efforts to reclaim young people who had joined Shincheonji.

In the first case, on 11th August 2022, the Supreme Court overturned an earlier ruling that had held Shincheonji Church of Jesus liable for damages and remitted the case for further proceedings.

The church subsequently secured another victory in the second case. On 27th February last year, the Supreme Court dismissed an appeal brought by a former member of the Chuncheon Church, thereby bringing the second Youth Reclamation Lawsuit to a close in Shincheonji’s favour.

With the latest appellate ruling upholding the original dismissal, Shincheonji Church of Jesus has now prevailed in this third case as well.

An official representative of Shincheonji Church of Jesus welcomed the decision, stating: “We welcome the court’s ruling. Once again, it demonstrates that allegations made by some established churches concerning brainwashing, coercive evangelism and excessive pressure to make financial offerings are not supported by the findings of the court.”

The representative further commented: “This decision will hopefully provide some comfort to the believers who have endured considerable difficulties while remaining steadfast in their faith.”

The official concluded by expressing hope for those who had brought the proceedings, saying: “I will continue to pray for the plaintiffs, that they may move away from pursuing indiscriminate legal action that seeks to damage the reputations of others and instead find peace.”

You May Also Like

2 comments

  1. thanks for sharing. do you have the ruling or can get it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The detailed ruling can be read at the Korean Court's Public Judicial Info Portal. But the portal is only available in Korean, and requires approximately $1 per ruling :) And you should be Korean to sign-in into the portal to read the ruling.

      Delete