Shincheonji Chairman ManHee Lee’s Bail Application: Upholding the Right to a Fair Defence
![]() |
| Dr. Massimo Introvigne, Director of the Center for Studies on New Religions (CESNUR) and Sociologist of Religion |
On 6th August, I visited ManHee Lee, Chairman of the Shincheonji Church of Jesus, at the Seoul Detention Centre, accompanied by Hans Noot of Human Rights Without Frontiers (HRWF) and Thierry Valle of CAP-LC. The 95-year-old religious leader, dressed in prison clothing, spoke calmly and reflected on the Bible.
Having met Chairman Lee in person, I am concerned about his circumstances, particularly in view of his advanced age. I therefore believe his situation warrants humanitarian consideration. As an elderly defendant, he should be afforded the opportunity to manage his health, prepare his defence and participate meaningfully in the trial. Furthermore, the question of bail should be considered separately from any decision to suspend detention temporarily for medical reasons.
It is important to distinguish between the granting of bail and the determination of guilt or innocence. Bail does not imply either an admission or a rejection of the charges. Rather, it allows the judicial process to continue while ensuring that the defendant can properly exercise his right to a defence.
Trial preparation is not limited to the days on which hearings take place. It is an ongoing process involving the organisation of evidence, understanding of legal procedures and preparation of responses to the allegations. The longer proceedings continue, the greater the burden on an elderly defendant who remains in detention. In these circumstances, I believe there are reasonable grounds to consider bail for Chairman Lee, subject to appropriate alternative measures that would ensure his attendance at future proceedings.
Another concern is the potential impact of religious stigma on the judicial process. I am deeply troubled by the possibility that individuals labelled as leaders of 'heretical cults' by religious opponents, politicians or the media may face prejudice or unequal treatment within the justice system. Negative perceptions of a particular religious movement must never determine how its leaders are treated under the law.
In a democratic society, the judiciary must reach its decisions independently of political rhetoric and media commentary. Yet, as a sociologist, I recognise that separating the wider public and political climate from judicial proceedings is not always straightforward in practice. This makes impartial academic research and objective assessment of Chairman Lee and Shincheonji all the more important. Those directly involved should also have the opportunity to present their perspectives and engage constructively in such assessments.
Ultimately, public confidence in the judiciary depends not only on the outcome of a case but also on the fairness and integrity of the process. Ensuring that even highly controversial defendants enjoy equal protection and the full exercise of their legal rights is an important demonstration of the independence, impartiality and fairness of South Korea's judicial system.
Dr. Massimo Introvigne | Director of the Center for Studies on New Religions (CESNUR) and Sociologist of Religion
![]() |
| ManHee Lee, Chairman of Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony |
Source: vo.la/vhLnIan



0 comments